Welcome to the
Caroline Hall Hennig Agency


Welcome to Caroline Hall Hennig Agency.

We are here to help serve all of your insurance needs. We are located in Harrison, Ohio. This allows us to serve you in Ohio, Indiana and Kentucky! When it comes to selecting an insurance company, what's most important to you? Financial strength? Performance? Reliability? Competitive prices? Superior service? A local presence? To learn more about us, click any item on our menu. If you have comments or questions, let us know by clicking Contact Us. Thanks for visiting and please let us now how we can serve you!

About Us

Protecting Futures

We have years of insurance experience helping clients prepare for the unknown. Ask us about:

  • Home
  • Auto
  • Life
  • Farm
  • Business/Commercial
  • Personal Property

We can access many different insurance products so you can get the right one to protect you and what matters most to you!

Our History

Caroline started her agency in 2009.  She became principal agent of the Harrison offices in 2010.

She is licensed in OH, IN, KY and MO.

Having grown up on a farm, Caroline takes a special interest in focusing on farm insurance.

Building Relationships

Everyone has different insurance needs. Call us today for a personalized business or individual assessment and find out how we can help protect your hard-earned assets. Whatever you need, we can take care of you!

About Caroline

Caroline is the first of three daughters to Paul and Jill Hall. She was raised being very involved in church, community events and the 4-H Foundation. Caroline graduated with honors from The University of Kentucky with a Bachelor of Science in Agriculture Economics and a Bachelor of Administration in Marketing. Caroline spent her high school years and the summers of her college years working for her father’s Nationwide Insurance agency. After college, Caroline went to work full time with her father before being given the opportunity to start her own agency.

Caroline married Sam Hennig in July of 2009. Sam grew up in the small town of Georgetown, Ohio in Brown County. He graduated from Cincinnati Christian University with a degree in Youth and Children's Ministry. Upon being given the opportunity to build and grow an insurance agency in Harrison, Caroline and Sam relocated from Brown County to Harrison. While Caroline is growing her agency in Harrison, Sam is the manager of the merchandising team at the Harrison Home Depot.

In March of 2017, Caroline and Sam welcome their first child, Lacey, into their family. Lacey is a happy, healthy little girl that brightens the life of her parents and Caroline's entire office team. 

Our Team

Amanda Patrick - Licensed Sales and Service Representative

Amanda joined the agency in 2013 and currently holds a property and casualty insurance license. She graduated from Colorado Tech University with a Bachelors of Administration in Medical Office Management. She is originally from Lexington, Kentucky, and now resides in Lawrenceburg, Indiana with her two sons Ethan (12) and Kadan (8). She is involved with the PAWS program of Dearborn County and enjoys spending time with her family.

Beth Perkins - Licensed Sales and Service Representative

Beth joined the agency in 2016 and currently holds her property and casualty insurance license. She grew up in the area and currently resides in Bright with her husband Dave and their three children, Erik (13), Riley (9) and Trevor (8). She has an extensive background in top notch customer service. In her free time Beth enjoys music, games, art and cooking.

Ashley Dornette - Student Administrative Assistant

Ashley joined the agency in 2015 and is currently a senior at Harrison High School. She lives with her family in Harrison, Ohio. Ashley is a member of National Honor Society, Key Club, and Health Occupation Student of America. She maintains a 4.3 GPA while participating in varsity cheerleading for football and basketball. In her free time she babysits her neighbors and enjoys spending time with her family, friends and two dogs. Ashley hopes to attend the University of Cincinnati for Early Childhood Education and after she graduates high school.

Marianne Pottorf - Administrative Assistant

Marianne joined the agency at the beginning of 2017. She has been married to her husband Calvin for 8 years and has 2 grown daughters and 2 grandchildren. Before joining the agency part time she retired from the IRS after working for 27 years. She enjoys reading novels and attending pee-wee football games and cheerleading competitions with her family. She says that working part time here is the perfect fit for my retired lifestyle and all the people here are wonderful and make me feel like I have found a "home" here.

Sam Hennig - Office Manager

Sam is married to primary agent Caroline Hall Hennig. Sam grew up in the small town of Georgetown, Ohio in Brown County. He graduated  from Cincinnati Christian University with a degree in Youth and Children's  Ministry. In addition to working for his wife's agency, he is the manager of the Merchandising Team for Home  Depot in Harrison. Sam is involved in the Bright Christian Church, and enjoys his time  working with the children's ministry. In his free time he likes spending time  with family, hunting and playing fast pitch softball.

Community Involvment

2017 Hamilton County 4-H Top Exhibitors

In the Hamilton County 4-H program the top honor you can receive for all your hard work is to be awarded the "Top Exhibitor Award". In 2014 when Caroline realize the kids were not given anything other than recognition she decided to not only take on sponsoring the award, but to expand the Top Exhibitor Award to include a top junior as well as a reserve top senior and reserve top junior. This expansion allows the students who are too young for the senior division to still have something to strive for as well as a second place winner in each class so the youth continue to push themselves and better their skills in the areas they choose. She awards the kids with a plaque they can keep distinguishing their achievements along with a monetary donation to put back into their project. Caroline feels this award sponsorship is a good way for her to support the youth of the county in a meaningful way.

Being raised a 4-H Member Caroline also has become involved with several local 4-H groups and was asked to serve as the Hamilton County 4-H Rabbit Supervisor. Caroline has helped 4-H members learn how to handle and care for their animals and she hopes she can help instill confidence and pride in the student members. Caroline’s service to 4-H in the local area counties is just beginning but she hopes it will help bring the rural community closer to a business based on rural foundations.


Community involvement is extremely important to Caroline. She is involved in many different aspects of the community such as local parades, the annual Santa event her agency puts on each year, booths at local fairs, and she plans to continue to grow her involvement. 


Caroline and Sam are also active with their church. They are members of the Bright Christian Church where Sam also serves as a deacon. Together they serve as a Children’s “Faithville” volunteer as well as the leaders for "Zone 45", a youth goup for 4th and 5th graders,. In addition they also serve as VBS volunteers each year to reach many other kids in the community.

Contact Me

Sign up to have us contact you to review your insurance.

Contact Us

Contact Us for a Free Quote Today!

Caroline Hall Hennig Agency

1117 Harrison Ave, Harrison, Ohio 45030, United States

(513) 367-7000


Monday - Friday: 8am - 5pm

Saturday: 9am - 1pm

Sunday: Closed

Evening by Appointment

Send Message